- Browse:
- Collections
- Subjects
- Creators
- Record Groups
Judge Edward J. Devitt Papers, 1927-1992
Collection Overview
Title: Judge Edward J. Devitt Papers, 1927-1992
ID: OGLMC1253
Primary Creator: Devitt, Edward J. (1911-1992)
Extent: 57.5 Linear Feet
Date Acquired: 05/00/1992
Subjects: Legal, University of North Dakota - Alumni
Languages: English
Abstract
Scope and Contents of the Materials
The Judge Edward J. Devitt Papers date from 1927-1992 and have been divided into three series:
Series 1: Biographical Materials
Series 2: Criminal Cases
Series 3: Civil Cases
Collection Historical Note
Edward James Devitt, the son of a railroad round-house foreman, was born May 5, 1911 in St. Paul, Minnesota. All four of his grandparents were born in Ireland. He attended St. John's Preparatory School and then St. John's University in Collegeville, MN, after which he earned a Bachelor of Law degree at the University of North Dakota in 1935, and a Bachelor of Science degree in Commerce in 1938. Elected a municipal judge in East Grand Forks, MN in November, 1935, Devitt drew mention in a national "Believe It or Not" syndicated news feature as the youngest judge in the USA. Named an assistant attorney general in Minnesota in 1939, he also taught at the UND Law School.
During the Second World War, Devitt became a US Navy intelligence officer. Lt. Cdr. Devitt was the sole survivor of a kamikaze hit upon the radio compartment of the destroyer Caldwell in December 1944. Recovering after a six month hospital stay, he received a Purple Heart for injuries from this raid.
Elected to the US House of Representatives from St. Paul in 1946 (R, Minn.), Devitt served on the House Judiciary Committee. Defeated for re-election by Eugene McCarthy in 1948, Devitt practiced law in St. Paul until his election as Ramsey County Probate Judge in 1950. In 1954, Devitt was appointed a federal judge on the US District Court for Minnesota. Serving as Chief US District Judge for Minnesota since 1958, Devitt officially retired in 1981, but continued to hear numerous cases as a senior judge. Judge Devitt died March 2, 1992. His funeral, held in the St. Paul Cathedral, was attended by over 1,200 mourners.
During his lengthy tenure on the US District Court, Devitt became probably the most respected and influential district court judge in the nation. His decisions were seldom reversed on appeal. His booklet "Ten Commandments for the New Judge", written in 1961, has become standard reading. Among his most noted innovations was the use of six-person juries in federal civil cases; a practice that has since come to be used in nearly all of the 95 US District Courts nationwide. Judge Devitt is also co-author of Federal Jury Practice and Instructions, the standard reference book on this subject. During the years 1967-1971, Judge Devitt chaired the American Bar Association Legal Advisory Committee on Fair Trial - Free Press, which developed guidelines for news media and the bench in sensational cases so as to avoid prejudicial publicity that would prevent a fair trial.
Judge Devitt repeatedly turned aside opportunities for promotion to appellate courts or to other positions removed from trial law. Dedicated to improving the judicial art, Devitt sought to write decisions and opinions which could be easily understood by those not trained in legal terminology. An active Catholic, Judge Devitt urged his fellow jurists to pray for divine guidance since "judges need that help more than anyone else."
West Publishing, a respected publisher in the field of law, in 1982 inaugurated the Edward J. Devitt Distinguished Service to Justice Award. This annual award, with a prize of $15,000, is given to the nation's foremost federal judge, as determined by a selection panel which frequently includes justices on the US Supreme Court. Judge Devitt served as Permanent Chairman of this selection panel.
Among Judge Devitt's most notable cases were the 1961 racketeering trial of Minneapolis gangster Isadore (Kid Cann) Blumenfeld, the 1963 fraud trial of former Minneapolis mayor Marvin Kline, the trial of the "Minnesota Eight" resisters of the Vietnam era draft, and the Reserve Mining environmental pollution trial of the mid 1970s. Judge Devitt also presided over several major organized crime trials in California and other states.
Subject/Index Terms
Administrative Information
Repository: Elwyn B. Robinson Department of Special Collections
Access Restrictions: Open for inspection under the rules and regulations of the Elwyn B. Robinson Department of Special Collections.
Acquisition Source: Terese Hoffman, St. Paul, Minnesota
Acquisition Method: Donation; Acc.92-1822 and Acc.92-1823
Preferred Citation: (Description of Item). Judge Edward J. Devitt Papers. OGLMC 1253, Box #, Folder #. Elwyn B. Robinson Department of Special Collections, Chester Fritz Library, University of North Dakota, Grand Forks.
Finding Aid Revision History: Finding aid migrated to Archon in March 2015.
Box and Folder Listing
Browse by Series:
[Series 1: Biographical Material],
[Series 2: Criminal Cases],
[Series 3: Civil Cases],
[Photographs :],
[All]
- Series 3: Civil Cases
- Box 32
- Folder 1: Charges to the Jury - Civil Cases, 1955-57 #1
- Folder 2: Charges to the Jury - Civil Cases, 1955-57 #2
- Folder 3: Charges to the Jury - Civil Cases, 1959-62
- Folder 4: Charges to the Jury - Civil Cases, 1964-66
- Folder 5: Charges to the Jury - Civil Cases, 1967-70
- Folder 6: AMOCO Canada Petroleum Co., etc. v. Lakehead Pipe Line Co., etc., et al, Civ. 6-76-439. At issue were damages for natural gas lost in a pipeline rupture accident. Summary judgement motion (granted), appeal (unsuccessful).
- Folder 7: Archie's Kwik Shop v. United States, Civ. 4-78-23. A grocery store succeeded in reducing length of a suspension from the Food Stamp program for a series of minor violations. Records include Food Stamp program forms and contact reports, and signed petitions by grocery store patrons.
- Folder 8: David L. Arneson v. Gary Gygax and TSR Hobbies, etc., Civ. 4-79-109. The original author of the game "Dungeons and Dragons" sued for unpaid royalties on later adapted versions.
- Folder 9: Assoc. General Contractors, etc., et al v. Construction and General Laborers Local No. 563, etc., et al, Civ. 3-74-56. Suit for damages arising from picketing alleged to be an illegal secondary boycott. I
- Folder 10: Assoc. General Contractors, etc., et al v. Construction and General Laborers Local No. 563, etc., et al II
- Folder 11: Ernestine W. Belton v. Greater Minneapolis Day Care Assoc., et al, Civ. 4-75-349. Plaintiff alleged racial discrimination in her being fired from a day care position. Documents include a 28 page history of the origins of this publicly funded day care organization in years 1967-73.
- Folder 12: In Re Grand Jury Proceedings Involving Berkley and Company, et al, Misc. 3-79-3. The general manager of Berkley and Co., an importer of fishing tackle, was under investigation for obstruction of justice in attempting to evade grand jury subpoenas relating to bribery of Taiwanese officials, company-paid tours to "notorious brothels" in Taiwan, and customs violations. I
- Folder 13: In Re Grand Jury Proceedings Involving Berkley and Company, et al II
- Folder 14: In Re Grand Jury Proceedings Involving Berkley and Company, et al III This case continues in Box 35 folders 3 through 7.
- Box 33
- Folder 1: Bio-Medicus, Inc., et al v. Shareholders' Committee in Opposition, etc., et al, Civ. 4-77-298. Two former directors of Bio-Medicus sought unsuccessfully to enjoin the convening of the 1979 annual shareholders' meeting, as part of an ongoing proxy fight.
- Folder 2: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al, Civ. 3-83-1070. Several Twin Cities printing firms sought to recover multimillion dollar losses resulting from a major strike marred by violence. Unions contested that plaintiffs provoked the strike through a hard-line "union busting" position which would have "radically reduced" wage scales and benefits built up over the previous sixty years. Documents include detailed transcripts of union-management negotiating sessions. This folder consists of correspondence and memoranda which outline the case.
- Folder 3: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al II
- Folder 4: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al III
- Folder 5: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al IV
- Folder 6: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al V
- Folder 7: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al VI
- Folder 8: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al VII
- Folder 9: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al VIII
- Folder 10: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al IX
- Folder 11: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al X
- Folder 12: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al XI
- Box 34
- Folder 1: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al XII
- Folder 2: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al XIII
- Folder 3: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al XIV
- Folder 4: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al XV
- Folder 5: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al XVI
- Folder 6: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al XVII
- Folder 7: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al XVIII
- Folder 8: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al XIX
- Folder 9: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al XX
- Folder 10: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al XXI
- Folder 11: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al XXII
- Folder 12: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al XXIII
- Box 35
- Folder 1: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al XXIV
- Folder 2: Bolger Publications, et al v. Graphic Communications Int'l. Union, etc., et al XXV
- Folder 3: In Re Grand Jury Proceedings Involving Berkley and Company, et al IV Continued from Box 32 folders 12 to 14.
- Folder 4: In Re Grand Jury Proceedings Involving Berkley and Company, et al V
- Folder 5: In Re Grand Jury Proceedings Involving Berkley and Company, et al VI
- Folder 6: In Re Grand Jury Proceedings Involving Berkley and Company, et al VII
- Folder 7: In Re Grand Jury Proceedings Involving Berkley and Company, et al VIII
- Folder 8: William H. Black v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co., Civ. 3- 77-205. Age discrimination suit, decided by jury in favor of a 58-year-old employee who was demoted to a lower paying position.
- Folder 9: D.H. Blattner & Sons, Inc. v. Local No. 49, etc., Civ. 6-78-483. Judge Devitt upheld an arbitrator's award of higher wages claimed by the union, based on a question of map interpretation as to the location between two wage districts of a rural job site.
- Folder 10: Homer A. Bonhiver, Trustee in Bankruptcy of New World Inns v. Johnson Bros. Wholesale Liquor Co., Civ. 4-79-309. A disputed amount of fifteen thousand dollars was collectible by New World Inns as part of a class action suit against Minnesota liquor wholesalers, but technicalities of the bankruptcy process prevented its being offset from Johnson Bros. share of the bankruptcy estate.
- Folder 11: John Carroll v. Texaco, Inc., et al, Civ. 4-74-541. A service station owner was unsuccessful in a suit for damages against various firms and individuals connected with the repossession of his service station for unpaid debts.
- Folder 12: Cardiac Pacemakers, Inc. v. Coratomic, Inc., Civ. 3-78-207. Suit and countersuit concerning patent and trademark rights to a particular heart pacemaker design. Exhibits include technical manuals and trade brochures. I
- Folder 13: Cardiac Pacemakers, Inc. v. Coratomic, Inc. II
- Folder 14: Robert Eugene Carter v. Jack G. Young, Commissioner of Corrections, et al, Civ. 3-79-176. Unsuccessful suit for damages by a prison inmate after a prison guard spat in his face.
- Box 36
- Folder 1: Chamfer Engineering v. Tapco Int'l., et al, Civ. 3-78-79. Plaintiff challenged several patents on devices used in the welding trade, alleging unfair competition on the part of defendants. I
- Folder 2: Chamfer Engineering v. Tapco Int'l., et al II
- Folder 3: John A. Cochrane v. Iowa Beef Processors, Inc., et al, Civ. 3-79-304. A suit for damages from "abuse of process" in an earlier suit involving the Amalgamated Meat Cutters Union. I
- Folder 4: John A. Cochrane v. Iowa Beef Processors, Inc., et al II
- Folder 5: George Deretich v. City of St. Francis, et al, Civ. 3-83-942. A local real estate developer was forced into foreclosure after refusing to pay city assessments for sewer and road services to his newly built shopping center. He later filed suit for damages, alleging that he was forced out of business by an anti-developer conspiracy running city government. His suit was dismissed by summary judgement, which judgement was upheld on appeal, and double attorney fees were assessed. This folder includes major hearing transcripts, orders, and appeals documents which best summarize the case. I
- Folder 6: George Deretich v. City of St. Francis, et al II
- Folder 7: George Deretich v. City of St. Francis, et al III
- Folder 8: George Deretich v. City of St. Francis, et al IV
- Folder 9: George Deretich v. City of St. Francis, et al V
- Folder 10: George Deretich v. City of St. Francis, et al VI
- Folder 11: George Deretich v. City of St. Francis, et al VII
- Box 37
- Folder 1: George Deretich v. City of St. Francis, et al VIII
- Folder 2: George Deretich v. City of St. Francis, et al IX
- Folder 3: George Deretich v. City of St. Francis, et al X
- Folder 4: George Deretich v. City of St. Francis, et al XI
- Folder 5: George Deretich v. City of St. Francis, et al XII
- Folder 6: District Lodge No. 77 of International Association of Machinists, etc. v. E. L. Murphy Trucking Co., Civ. 3-79-100. Suit to compel arbitration in a dispute concerning seniority issues in new hiring, as opposed to rehiring, to fill a foreman's position.
- Folder 7: . Elbow Lake (Village of), Minnesota v. Otter Tail Power Co., Civ. 6-67- 244. Otter Tail Power Company filed briefs requesting Judge Devitt to remove himself from the case, on grounds that he had recently presided over a similar case against the defendant. Plaintiff opposed this request, but Judge Devitt issued an order to have the case reassigned.
- Folder 8: Elwood Flick, et al v. Arthur Noot, et al, Civ. 4-78-359. A class action suit which resulted in expanded rights for institutionalized mentally retarded individuals in Minnesota. File includes letters from service organizations commenting on a stipulated agreement settling the suit.
- Folder 9: Miscellaneous civil briefs and correspondence regarding plaintiffs whose last names begin with "A" through "G"
- Folder 10: Marguerite Gamble v. University of Minnesota, et al, Civ. 4-76-223. Plaintiff alleged dismissal from University of Minnesota Medical School on racial grounds. Appeals Court affirmed Judge Devitt's decision that her dismissal was actually for nondiscriminatory academic reasons. Files include photocopied newspaper articles concerning the case, and also leaflets for protest meetings in support of plaintiff. I
- Folder 11: Marguerite Gamble v. University of Minnesota, et al II
- Folder 12: Katherine Hiduchenko v. Minneapolis Medical and Diagnostic Center, et al, Civ. 4-79-264. Suit by a female physician of Ukrainian descent, alleging that dismissal from employment was due to her sex and national origin.
- Box 38
- Folder 1: Jane E. Hodgson, M.D., et al v. Gary W. Flakne, et al, Civ. 4-76-293. A class action suit challenging newly enacted restrictions on second-trimester abortions was referred back to Minnesota state court by a three-judge panel of federal court judges which included Devitt. Exhibits include numerous affidavits and correspondence related to the viability for survival of 20-week-old fetuses. I Jane E. Hodgson, M.D., et al v. Gary W. Flakne, et al II
- Folder 2: Jane E. Hodgson, M.D., et al v. Gary W. Flakne, et al II
- Folder 3: Infilco Degremont, Inc. v. Beatrice Foods Co., Civ. 3-77-159. Suit for damages related to a defective water treatment plant.
- Folder 4: Insurers Action Council, Inc., et al v. Michael Markman, Commissioner of Insurance, et al, Civ. 3-76-440. Notes and correspondence from a case in which Minnesota health insurance firms challenged new state regulations which required them to offer policies to residents who would not otherwise qualify for major medical coverage.
- Folder 5: Joseph P. Hansen, Trustee of Local Union P-9 v. Lynn Huston, et al, Civ. 3-86-437, 3-86-490, and 3-86-960. A dispute concerning management and control of a United Food and Commercial Workers union local was fought out at length in court, with Judge Devitt's rulings in favor of the parent union being upheld on appeal. The dispute was triggered by Local P-9's decision to continue supporting a strike and boycott against Hormel even after the parent union ordered such support to stop. Secondary issues included motions for restraining orders against strike propaganda activities and against defacement of a pro-strike mural painted in the Austin, MN local P-9 office building. This folder includes appeals court decisions, major orders, and news clippings which provide an overview of the case. I
- Folder 6: Joseph P. Hansen, Trustee of Local Union P-9 v. Lynn Huston, et al II
- Folder 7: Joseph P. Hansen, Trustee of Local Union P-9 v. Lynn Huston, et al III
- Folder 8: Joseph P. Hansen, Trustee of Local Union P-9 v. Lynn Huston, et al IV
- Folder 9: Joseph P. Hansen, Trustee of Local Union P-9 v. Lynn Huston, et al V
- Folder 10: Joseph P. Hansen, Trustee of Local Union P-9 v. Lynn Huston, et al VI
- Folder 11: Joseph P. Hansen, Trustee of Local Union P-9 v. Lynn Huston, et al VII
- Folder 12: Joseph P. Hansen, Trustee of Local Union P-9 v. Lynn Huston, et al VIII
- Box 39
- Folder 1: Joseph P. Hansen, Trustee of Local Union P-9 v. Lynn Huston, et al IX
- Folder 2: Joseph P. Hansen, Trustee of Local Union P-9 v. Lynn Huston, et al X
- Folder 3: Joseph P. Hansen, Trustee of Local Union P-9 v. Lynn Huston, et al XI
- Folder 4: Joseph P. Hansen, Trustee of Local Union P-9 v. Lynn Huston, et al XII
- Folder 5: Joseph P. Hansen, Trustee of Local Union P-9 v. Lynn Huston, et al XIII
- Folder 6: Joseph P. Hansen, Trustee of Local Union P-9 v. Lynn Huston, et al XIV
- Folder 7: Miscellaneous civil briefs and correspondence regarding plaintiffs whose last names begin with "H" through "J"
- Folder 8: Klapperich v. Navistar v. Koch Refining, et al, Civ. 3-85-1237. Suit for damages arising from a tractor fire. Navistar (aka International Harvester) filed a third party suit alleging that the fire was not caused by a defect in the tractor but rather by an excessively volatile grade of gasoline. This folder includes general briefs and correspondence providing a full history of the case. I
- Folder 9: Klapperich v. Navistar v. Koch Rfng., et al II
- Folder 10: Klapperich v. Navistar v. Koch Rfng., et al III
- Folder 11: Klapperich v. Navistar v. Koch Rfng., et al IV
- Folder 12: Klapperich v. Navistar v. Koch Rfng., et al V
- Folder 13: Klapperich v. Navistar v. Koch Rfng., et al VI
- Box 40
- Folder 1: Klapperich v. Navistar v. Koch Rfng., et al VII
- Folder 2: Klapperich v. Navistar v. Koch Rfng., et al VIII
- Folder 3: Klapperich v. Navistar v. Koch Rfng., et al IX
- Folder 4: Klapperich v. Navistar v. Koch Rfng., et al X
- Folder 5: Klapperich v. Navistar v. Koch Rfng., et al XI
- Folder 6: Klapperich v. Navistar v. Koch Rfng., et al XII
- Folder 7: Klapperich v. Navistar v. Koch Rfng., et al XIII
- Folder 8: Klapperich v. Navistar v. Koch Rfng., et al XIV
- Folder 9: Marvin Lumber and Cedar Co. v. Norton Co., Civ. 6-85-93. A manufacturer of windows based in Warroad, MN sued a supplier of sealants which turned out to be defective, resulting in massive failures of its products in the field. A settlement was eventually reached without going to trial. This folder contains general briefs, orders, and correspondence #1. I
- Folder 10: Marvin Lumber and Cedar Co. v. Norton Co. II
- Folder 11: Marvin Lumber and Cedar Co. v. Norton Co. III
- Box 41
- Folder 1: Marvin Lumber and Cedar Co. v. Norton Co. IV
- Folder 2: Marvin Lumber and Cedar Co. v. Norton Co. V
- Folder 3: Marvin Lumber and Cedar Co. v. Norton Co. VI
- Folder 4: Marvin Lumber and Cedar Co. v. Norton Co. VII
- Folder 5: Marvin Lumber and Cedar Co. v. Norton Co. VIII
- Folder 6: Marvin Lumber and Cedar Co. v. Norton Co. IX
- Folder 7: Marvin Lumber and Cedar Co. v. Norton Co. X
- Folder 8: Marvin Lumber and Cedar Co. v. Norton Co. XI
- Folder 9: Marvin Lumber and Cedar Co. v. Norton Co. XII
- Folder 10: Marvin Lumber and Cedar Co. v. Norton Co. XIII
- Box 42
- Folder 1: Minneapolis Community Development Agency, et al v. HUD, Civ. 3-86- 1046 and 3-87-65. A lawsuit, settled without trial, to prevent HUD from selling a large public housing development to the highest bidder. This folder contains briefs, orders, and correspondence. I
- Folder 2: Minneapolis Community Development Agency, et al v. HUD. Exhibits #1. II
- Folder 3: Minneapolis Community Development Agency, et al v. HUD. Exhibits #2. III
- Folder 4: Minneapolis Community Development Agency, et al v. HUD. Exhibits #3. IV.
- Folder 5: United States v. Walter Moorhouse, et al, Civ. 6-84-853. Suit to compel the firm "Armageddon, Inc." and related parties to produce for the IRS all business records pertaining to corporate trusts apparently set up to facilitate tax evasion, and to order an end to their marketing of business trusts as fraudulent tax shelters. I
- Folder 6: United States v. Walter Moorhouse, et al. II
- Folder 7: United States v. Walter Moorhouse, et al. III
- Folder 8: United States v. Walter Moorhouse, et al. IV
- Folder 9: United States v. Walter Moorhouse, et al. V
- Folder 10: United States v. Walter Moorhouse, et al. VI
- Folder 11: United States v. Walter Moorhouse, et al. VII
- Box 43
- Folder 1: Virginia Pikop v. Burlington Northern Railroad Co., et al, Civ. 3-84-351. Suit for damages arising from alleged sexual and emotional harassment of the plaintiff by her male supervisor and other male employees who resented her holding a "man's job" on a section crew and her refusal to assist in rodent control activities as part of this job. Jury found against the plaintiff. Exhibits include case histories of other sexual harassment proceedings filed earlier by other BN employees, all of which were ruled inadmissible and therefore not seen by the jury. This folder includes briefs, memoranda and orders. I
- Folder 2: Virginia Pikop v. Burlington Northern Railroad Co., et al. Briefs, memoranda, and orders #2. II
- Folder 3: Virginia Pikop v. Burlington Northern Railroad Co., et al. Briefs, memoranda, and orders #3. III
- Folder 4: Virginia Pikop v. Burlington Northern Railroad Co., et al. Briefs, memoranda, and orders #4. IV
- Folder 5: Virginia Pikop v. Burlington Northern Railroad Co., et al. Briefs, memoranda, and orders #5. V
- Folder 6: Virginia Pikop v. Burlington Northern Railroad Co., et al. Jury instructions #1. VI
- Folder 7: Virginia Pikop v. Burlington Northern Railroad Co., et al. Jury instructions #2, witness lists. VII
- Folder 8: Virginia Pikop v. Burlington Northern Railroad Co., et al. Affidavits. VIII
- Folder 9: Virginia Pikop v. Burlington Northern Railroad Co., et al. News clips, exhibits #1. IX
- Folder 10: Virginia Pikop v. Burlington Northern Railroad Co., et al. Exhibits #2. X
- Box 44
- Folder 1: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al, Civ. 5-72-19. A suit filed in 1972 led to Judge Devitt's 1976 decision to order Reserve Mining Co. to cease discharge of taconite tailings into Lake Superior. At issue were both public health concerns related to asbestos exposure in drinking water, and general environmental concerns. Judge Devitt entered into the case in January 1976 after Judge Miles Lord was ordered dismissed by a panel of Appeals Court judges who decided that he was not impartial but had been acting as an advocate for the prosecution. The case drew extensive public commentary, including numerous letters to Judges Lord and Devitt applauding their decisions to curtail a "notorious polluter." This file contains Judge's orders. I
- Folder 2: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al Appeals briefs and decisions. II
- Folder 3: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 4: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 5: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 6: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 7: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 8: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 9: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 10: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 11: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 12: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 13: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 14: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Box 45
- Folder 1: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 2: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 3: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 4: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 5: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 6: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 7: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 8: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 9: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 10: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 11: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Folder 12: United States, et al v. Reserve Mining Co., et al
- Box 46
- Folder 1: Jeffrey and Gene Schermerhorn v. Clayton H. Shrout, et al, Civ. 6-82- 1834/1835. Suit to collect on unpaid award of some $700,000 in damages arising from attorney malpractice which had resulted in plaintiffs losing their farm. This folder includes trial notes, orders, general memoranda, and correspondence. I
- Folder 2: Jeffrey and Gene Schermerhorn v. Clayton H. Shrout, et al
- Folder 3: Jeffrey and Gene Schermerhorn v. Clayton H. Shrout, et al
- Folder 4: Jeffrey and Gene Schermerhorn v. Clayton H. Shrout, et al
- Folder 5: Jeffrey and Gene Schermerhorn v. Clayton H. Shrout, et al
- Folder 6: Jeffrey and Gene Schermerhorn v. Clayton H. Shrout, et al
- Folder 7: Miscellaneous civil briefs and correspondence regarding plaintiffs whose last names begin with "M" through "Z"
- Folder 8: United States v. Jerome J. Schoenborn, Civ. 3-84-1662. A farmer who purchased land with easements to preserve wetlands was ordered to restore several basins and drainage ditches to their original condition, a decision largely upheld on appeal. I
- Folder 9: United States v. Jerome J. Schoenborn. II
- Folder 10: United States v. Jerome J. Schoenborn. III
- Folder 11: United States v. Jerome J. Schoenborn. IV
Browse by Series:
[Series 1: Biographical Material],
[Series 2: Criminal Cases],
[Series 3: Civil Cases],
[Photographs :],
[All]